% !TEX program = pdflatex
%=====================================================================
% X-J-ST.tex
% Standalone pdfLaTeX source.
% No external figures, source files, or bibliography database.
%
% No compilation, numerical execution, machine verification,
% repository registration, or independent review is asserted.
%=====================================================================

\documentclass[11pt]{article}

\usepackage[T1]{fontenc}
\usepackage[utf8]{inputenc}
\usepackage{lmodern}
\usepackage[margin=1in]{geometry}
\usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsthm,mathtools}
\usepackage{mathrsfs}
\usepackage{array,booktabs,tabularx,longtable}
\usepackage{enumitem}
\usepackage{microtype}
\usepackage[hidelinks]{hyperref}

\hypersetup{
 pdftitle={X-J-ST: A second charged coefficient and a selective amplitude package on a prescribed conical Enter spacetime},
 pdfauthor={Ngo Cheung},
 pdfsubject={Classical coefficient extraction, selective distinguishability,
 complete destructive instruments, and charge-matching boundaries}
}

\setlength{\emergencystretch}{3em}
\setlist{itemsep=3pt,topsep=5pt}
\setcounter{tocdepth}{1}
\numberwithin{equation}{section}
\allowdisplaybreaks
\urlstyle{same}

\newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section]
\newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma}
\newtheorem{proposition}[theorem]{Proposition}
\newtheorem{corollary}[theorem]{Corollary}
\theoremstyle{definition}
\newtheorem{definition}[theorem]{Definition}
\newtheorem{assumption}[theorem]{Assumption}
\theoremstyle{remark}
\newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark}

\newcommand{\RR}{\mathbb R}
\newcommand{\CC}{\mathbb C}
\newcommand{\HH}{\mathcal H}
\newcommand{\dd}{\mathrm d}
\newcommand{\id}{\operatorname{id}}
\newcommand{\Alg}{\mathcal A}
\newcommand{\Fml}{\mathscr F_{\mathrm{ml}}}
\newcommand{\Lie}{\mathcal L}
\newcommand{\Ptr}{\mathsf P_{\mathrm{tr}}}
\newcommand{\Cop}{\mathsf C}
\newcommand{\Pgr}{\mathsf P_{\mathrm{gr}}}
\newcommand{\Pm}{P_m}
\newcommand{\grel}{\mathfrak g_U}
\newcommand{\SI}{\mathcal S_{\lambda}^{[3]}}
\newcommand{\Stilde}{\widetilde{\mathcal S}_{\lambda}}
\newcommand{\QI}{Q_{\lambda}^{[3]}}
\newcommand{\Hkin}{\mathcal H_s}
\newcommand{\Cfirst}{\mathcal C_1}
\newcommand{\Csecond}{\mathcal C_2}
\newcommand{\Jcharge}{\mathcal J}
\newcommand{\TV}{d_{\mathrm{TV}}}
\newcommand{\dtr}{d_{\mathrm{tr}}}
\newcommand{\ddia}{d_\diamond}
\newcommand{\pair}[2]{\left\langle #1,#2\right\rangle}
\newcommand{\norm}[1]{\left\lVert #1\right\rVert}
\newcommand{\abs}[1]{\left\lvert #1\right\rvert}
\newcommand{\ket}[1]{\lvert #1\rangle}
\newcommand{\bra}[1]{\langle #1\rvert}
\newcommand{\kb}[2]{\ket{#1}\bra{#2}}
\newcommand{\proj}[1]{\kb{#1}{#1}}
\newcommand{\loc}[1]{\texttt{\detokenize{#1}}}

\DeclareMathOperator{\supp}{supp}
\DeclareMathOperator{\Tr}{Tr}
\DeclareMathOperator{\tr}{tr}
\DeclareMathOperator{\Ad}{Ad}
\DeclareMathOperator{\gh}{gh}
\DeclareMathOperator{\sech}{sech}
\DeclareMathOperator{\diag}{diag}

\newcommand{\statementbox}[2]{%
 \par\medskip\noindent
 \fbox{\begin{minipage}{%
 \dimexpr\linewidth-2\fboxsep-2\fboxrule\relax}
 \textbf{#1}\par\smallskip #2
 \end{minipage}}
 \par\medskip
}

\title{\textbf{X-J-ST: A second charged coefficient\\
and a selective amplitude package}\\[4pt]
\large Finite classical response data, positive report separation,\\
and complete destructive instruments on the prescribed I-B host}
\author{Ngo Cheung}
\date{}

\begin{document}
\maketitle

\begin{abstract}
We construct an explicit second charged scalar coefficient
from the compact third-order interaction of X-I-ST, without
changing its action, the prescribed conical host, or the fixed
positive regulator width. Two disjoint third polarizations of
the quartic vertex give independently variable compact moments.
Their infinitesimal charge matrix has rank two. On a specified
local common-flow family their charges agree exactly, whereas
a separate compact gauge direction disproves charge matching
on the whole relative algebra. The construction therefore
supplies a genuine second coefficient for the present selective
package, but not the missing universal reference for the
earlier convolution observable.

For a supplied value \(d\), an explicit destructive
amplitude instrument retains a failure outcome of probability
\(r\) and has the exact separation
\[
 \Delta(d)=\frac{1-r}{2}
                \left|\tanh\!\left(\frac{\nu d}{\sigma}\right)\right|.
\]
It is positive precisely when the signal is nonzero and the
nonfailure probability is positive. A finite calibration
instance has the exact gap \(3/16\), with no numerical
quadrature. We prove the corresponding finite-dictionary
formula, a complete residual-and-reference instrument
identity, an encoding-level higher-order visibility test,
and explicit error margins. An additional two-coefficient
phase instrument is invariant under the specified common
charge direction, including all selective outputs and
untouched references, but retains periodic aliases and
does not become invariant under independent charge directions.

The principal contribution is the explicit separation between
independent classical coefficient construction, restricted
charge matching, and complete finite report distinguishability.
This provides a controlled calibration target for later
interfaces without treating encoded visibility as continuum
acquisition or gauge restoration. The measurement identities
are finite-dimensional, and the coefficient calculations are
classical. The X-I-ST BV structure is unchanged through its
retained order; the three-tree plateau is counted once;
the reciprocity and convolution obstructions remain separate.
No interacting quantum BRST differential, characteristic
quantum coefficient, loop-anomaly cancellation, ultraviolet
completion, or spacetime emergence is constructed.
\end{abstract}

\statementbox{Exact scope of the second coefficient}{%
The second coefficient constructed here is a compact scalar
response coefficient extracted from the X-I-ST interaction.

It is independent of the first moment in this paper and is
charged under explicitly specified relative scalar variations.
A common charge is realized on a declared local comparison
family.

It is \emph{not} identified with a second reference having the
required charge matching to the original convolution
coefficient on its whole frozen gauge algebra. That stronger
application remains unconstructed.}

\tableofcontents

%=====================================================================
\section{Purpose, terminology, and the Enter discipline}
\label{sec:introduction}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{What the construction adds}

The plan requires a second coefficient, a positive selective
total-variation gap, and complete instruments. These are
different requirements.

A nonzero number chosen to cancel another number is not an
independently defined coefficient. A nonzero classical
coefficient need not be visible in every encoding. A positive
outcome-law gap does not determine the surviving quantum
output. Finally, matching charges along one direction does
not establish invariance under an entire gauge algebra.

The construction below addresses these points separately:
\begin{enumerate}
\item two compact moments are obtained by finite polarization
of the already specified X-I-ST vertex;
\item their values and their charge directions are explicitly
constructed rather than assumed;
\item a fixed amplitude readout gives a positive finite-task
gap, with all failure probability included;
\item the complete selective maps, references, finite
composition, and prescribed transport are proved;
\item the precise failure of whole-algebra charge matching
is exhibited.
\end{enumerate}

The scalar moment construction is elementary. The general
theory of classical BV and finite-dimensional instruments
is not new \cite{FRBV,DaviesLewis,Watrous}. The contribution
is the supported assembly and the exact distinction between
its positive result and the stronger reference construction
that it does not provide.

\subsection{Meaning of ``charged'' and ``second''}

\begin{definition}[Charge convention]
\label{def:charge}
For a ghost-number-zero scalar functional \(F[\phi]\),
and a compact vector field \(\xi\), define its scalar
variation charge by
\[
 q_F(\phi;\xi)
       =\left.\frac{\dd}{\dd t}\right|_{t=0}
                          F[\phi\circ F_t^\xi],
\]
where \(F_t^\xi\) is the flow of \(\xi\).

The term \emph{charged} means that this derivative is
nonzero on some declared data. It does not mean an
electric charge, a conserved Noether charge, or a
nonzero ghost number.
\end{definition}

The two coefficients in this paper are both ghost-number
zero. Their BRST variations have ghost number one.
The second coefficient is independent of the first
moment constructed here. Neither moment is identified
with the convolution coefficient of X-A-conv.

The order of a coefficient in the classical action and
the order of a signal in a finite encoding will also
be kept distinct.

\subsection{Enter: background and four non-identifications}

Cheung's Enter calculus distinguishes a destructive
measurement interface from a quantum-return interface
\cite{CheungEnter,EnterI}. A measured quantum name is
consumed from the accessible quantum output. The output
contains a classical record and the unmeasured residual
systems. This is an access statement, not a claim that
every physical implementing degree of freedom is
annihilated.

The philosophical account \cite{EnterPhilosophy} keeps
four distinctions:
\begin{enumerate}
\item consuming a measured register does not recover an
unknown quantum code;
\item a stored classical outcome is not a coherent decoder;
\item specifying an input--output channel does not specify
a heat, work, or reset model;
\item resemblance between constructions does not establish
a physical dictionary.
\end{enumerate}

For the present manuscript these imply, in particular,
\[
 \text{coefficient definition}\ne
 \text{continuum acquisition},
 \qquad
 \text{record law}\ne
 \text{complete instrument},
\]
and
\[
 \text{finite encoding}\ne
 \text{quantum field product},
 \qquad
 \text{prescribed host}\ne
 \text{emergent spacetime}.
\]

The instruments below use specified Born semantics.
No characterization theorem is rederived from shortened
names for its hypotheses.

\subsection{Source and dependency discipline}

The supplied X-I-ST source is the classical predecessor
\cite{XIST}. X-Enter and X-Enter-ST supply the amplitude,
selective-output, and conditional-reference comparisons
\cite{XEnter,XEnterST}. X-H-ST and X-G-ST distinguish
relative classical BV, free causal BRST, and failure of
automatic free-shell descent \cite{XHST,XGST}.

All formulas needed for the new coefficient and report
theorems are given below. A repository connection is not
used as a proof. Conversely, an explicitly stated
mathematical hypothesis does not cease to be a hypothesis
merely because a documentary connection is called a
separation.

%=====================================================================
\section{The unchanged host and its finite operational reserve}
\label{sec:host}
%=====================================================================

\begin{assumption}[Retained I-B/X-A-ST host]
\label{ass:host}
Retain the same conical product, supported chart, width,
time orientation, and finite operational permissions
as in X-I-ST. In regular conical coordinates,
\[
 \mathcal M^\circ
  =\RR_T\times(C_\alpha\setminus\{o\})\times\RR_z,
 \qquad
 G=-c_{\mathrm h}^2\dd T^2+\dd r^2+
                \alpha^2r^2\dd\varphi^2+\dd z^2,
\]
with the inherited \(0<\alpha<1\) and \(c_{\mathrm h}>0\).
The completion defect is the worldsheet
\[
 \mathcal W=\RR_T\times\{o\}\times\RR_z.
\]

The independent analytical completion and supported chart are
\[
 \widehat M=\RR^{1+3},\qquad
 \eta=\diag(1,-1,-1,-1),\qquad
 \iota:\mathcal L\longrightarrow\mathcal M^\circ,
\]
\[
 \iota^*G=-\eta,\qquad
 t=c_{\mathrm h}(T-T_\Sigma).
\]
The chart is injective on the retained domain, and its
laboratory reserve is disjoint from \(\mathcal W\).

Retain a nonempty relatively compact plateau
\[
 \overline U\Subset\mathcal L,\qquad
 g=\sigma_\varepsilon=1
       \quad\text{near }\overline U,\qquad
 \varepsilon>0
\]
with the same positive width as before.

Any finite experiment released below must fit the
already supplied time, space, register, and control
reserve. Register allocation is charged; no enlargement
of the chart or change of \(\varepsilon\) is inferred.
\end{assumption}

This is the prescribed-background meaning of I-B
\cite{IB,XAST}. The analytical metric \(\eta\), formal
field metrics, and host metric \(G\) remain different
objects.

\begin{proposition}[Non-global-hyperbolicity boundary]
The regular conical product is not globally hyperbolic.
The finite constructions in this paper require no global
conical Green operator.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
Fix a radial ray and \(r_0>0\). For
\(A>r_0/c_{\mathrm h}\), the diamond between
\((-A,r_0,\varphi_0,z_0)\) and
\((A,r_0,\varphi_0,z_0)\) contains
\[
 (0,r_0/n,\varphi_0,z_0),\qquad n\ge1.
\]
The sequence approaches the excluded apex and has no
convergent subsequence in the regular product.
The diamond is not compact.

All coefficient calculations below are compact smooth
integrals on \(\widehat M\), represented inside the
retained chart. No inverse on \(\mathcal M^\circ\)
is used.
\end{proof}

A compact density is transported by the full
change-of-variables formula. Thus, for \(y=\iota(x)\),
\[
 L(x)\dd^4x
 =L(\iota^{-1}(y))
      \abs{\det D\iota^{-1}(y)}\,\dd^4y.
\]
Dual antifield densities are transported compatibly.
No coordinate Jacobian is silently dropped.

%=====================================================================
\section{The retained classical interface and its recovery}
\label{sec:classical}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{Fields and field differential}

Use the independent fields
\[
 \Phi=(r_{\mu\nu},\phi,c^\mu,\bar c_\mu,b_\mu),
\]
of respective parities \(0,0,1,1,0\) and ghost numbers
\(0,0,1,-1,0\). The auxiliary field \(b\) remains independent.

With fixed smooth backgrounds \(h,k\), write
\[
 \bar q=\eta+\kappa h+\kappa^2k,\qquad
 q=\bar q+\kappa r.
\]
The field differential is
\begin{align}
 sr&=Kc+\kappa\Lie_c(h+r)+\kappa^2\Lie_ck,
 \label{eq:smetric}\\
 s\phi&=\kappa c^\mu\partial_\mu\phi,
 &sc^\mu&=\kappa c^\nu\partial_\nu c^\mu,
 \label{eq:sscalar}\\
 s\bar c&=b,
 &sb&=0,
 &sh&=sk=0,
 \label{eq:saux}
\end{align}
where
\[
 (Kc)_{\mu\nu}=\partial_\mu c_\nu+\partial_\nu c_\mu.
\]
The rules are left graded derivations commuting with
total derivatives.

\begin{lemma}[Field nilpotence]
\label{lem:snil}
The field differential satisfies \(s^2=0\) off shell.
Its zeroth-order part is
\[
 s_0r=Kc,\qquad s_0\phi=s_0c=s_0b=0,\qquad s_0\bar c=b.
\]
\end{lemma}

\begin{proof}
For the odd vector field \(c\), set
\(w^\mu=c^\nu\partial_\nu c^\mu\).
The graded Lie identity is
\(\Lie_c^2=\Lie_w\).
Since \(sq=\kappa\Lie_cq\) and \(sc=\kappa w\),
\[
 s^2q=\kappa\Lie_{sc}q-\kappa\Lie_c(sq)=0.
\]
The fixed background implies \(s^2r=0\).
The same identity on scalars gives \(s^2\phi=0\);
direct expansion gives \(s^2c=0\).
The nonminimal pair is nilpotent by definition.
\end{proof}

For compact relative directions use
\[
 \grel=C_c^\infty(U;T\widehat M).
\]
Compact test ghosts are not identified with nonzero
compactly supported homogeneous free ghost solutions.

\subsection{The finite action being retained}

The following gives a self-contained coefficient
specification of the X-I-ST interface.

For a formal metric \(p\), let \(J_p=\sqrt{-\det p}\).
Use the curvature convention
\[
 R_{\mu\nu}
 =\partial_\rho\Gamma^\rho_{\mu\nu}
  -\partial_\nu\Gamma^\rho_{\mu\rho}
  +\Gamma^\rho_{\rho\lambda}\Gamma^\lambda_{\mu\nu}
  -\Gamma^\rho_{\nu\lambda}\Gamma^\lambda_{\mu\rho},
\]
with the metric Christoffel formula, and put
\[
 \mathscr E[p]=J_p p^{\mu\nu}R_{\mu\nu}[p],
 \qquad
 L_p[\phi]=\frac12J_p
   (p^{\mu\nu}\partial_\mu\phi\partial_\nu\phi-m^2\phi^2).
\]
Let
\[
 C_{\bar q}^{\mu}[r]
 =\bar\nabla_\nu\left(
 \bar q^{\nu\alpha}\bar q^{\mu\beta}r_{\alpha\beta}
 -\frac12\bar q^{\nu\mu}\bar q^{\alpha\beta}r_{\alpha\beta}
 \right),
\]
\[
 \Psi_{\bar q}
 =\int J_{\bar q}\bar c_\mu
       (C_{\bar q}^{\mu}[r]-\bar q^{\mu\nu}b_\nu)\dd^4x.
\]
Define the local variational action
\begin{equation}
 I=-\frac1{2\kappa^2}
       \int(\mathscr E[q]-\mathscr E[\bar q])\dd^4x
       +\int L_q[\phi]\dd^4x+s\Psi_{\bar q}.
 \label{eq:referenceaction}
\end{equation}
The sole negative-order coefficient is a divergence,
\[
 -\frac1{2\kappa}
       (\partial_\mu\partial_\nu r^{\mu\nu}
                         -\Box\tr_\eta r).
\]
It is removed as a variational class before taking
nonnegative coefficients.

Adjoin canonical antifields with
\[
 |\Phi_A^*|=|\Phi^A|+1,\qquad
 \gh(\Phi_A^*)=-1-\gh(\Phi^A),
\]
and fix
\[
 (\Phi^A(x),\Phi_B^*(y))
       =\delta^A_B\delta(x-y).
\]
For a left Hamiltonian differential, use the signed lift
\begin{equation}
 \Hkin=\sum_A(-1)^{|\Phi^A|}
                         \int\Phi_A^*s\Phi^A\,\dd^4x.
 \label{eq:Hkin}
\end{equation}
Then \((\Hkin,\Phi^A)=s\Phi^A\).
In particular the antighost term is
\(-\int\bar c^{*\mu}b_\mu\dd^4x\).

Retain exactly the nonnegative coefficients through
order three:
\[
 \mathcal S_{\mathrm{ref}}^{[3]}
              =\sum_{j=0}^3\kappa^j[\kappa^j](I+\Hkin).
\]
The order-three gravitational coefficient uses the
order-five coefficient of \(\mathscr E[q]\).
No inversion of a nilpotent \(\kappa\) is performed.

Fix the inherited nonnegative, nonzero profile
\[
 a\in C_c^\infty(U;\RR),\qquad
 V_a=\frac1{4!}\int a\phi^4\dd^4x,
\]
and retain
\begin{equation}
 \SI=\mathcal S_{\mathrm{ref}}^{[3]}
                         +\lambda\kappa^3V_a
 \quad\text{over}\quad
 R_3=\RR[\lambda][\kappa]/(\kappa^4).
 \label{eq:SI}
\end{equation}
An ordinary polynomial representative of this expression
is denoted \(\Stilde\).

Local actions are understood modulo horizontal
divergences; ordinary products of compact local
functionals belong to the classical multilocal algebra
\(\Fml(U)\), not necessarily to the single-integral
local subspace \cite{FRBV,XHST,XIST}.

\begin{proposition}[Retained third-order master identity]
\label{prop:retainedCME}
Equation~\eqref{eq:SI} satisfies
\[
 \frac12(\SI,\SI)=0\pmod{\kappa^4},
 \qquad
 \QI F=(\SI,F),\qquad
 \QI^2=0\pmod{\kappa^4}.
\]
No term in this paper is added to that action.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
The signed lift obeys
\((\Hkin,\Phi^A)=s\Phi^A\) on every generator.
Its self-bracket is the cotangent lift of \(s^2\),
so it vanishes by Lemma~\ref{lem:snil}.

Naturality gives
\[
 s\mathscr E[q]
       =\kappa\partial_\mu(c^\mu\mathscr E[q]),
 \qquad
 sL_q=\kappa\partial_\mu(c^\mu L_q),
 \qquad
 s^2\Psi_{\bar q}=0.
\]
Thus the full formal reference Hamiltonian has zero
master square modulo divergences.
Its nonnegative truncation has zero coefficients
through order three.

The only new cross term from \(V_a\) starts at order
four because \(s_0\phi=0\), and \((V_a,V_a)=0\).
The odd Jacobi identity proves the differential claim.
\end{proof}

\subsection{Free-limit statements with the tadpole retained}

For clarity, define
\[
 (\Ptr r)_{\mu\nu}
     =r_{\mu\nu}-\frac12\eta_{\mu\nu}\tr_\eta r,
 \qquad
 (\Cop r)^\mu=\partial_\nu(\Ptr r)^{\nu\mu}.
\]
The free normalization is
\[
 A=\frac12G_{\mathrm{lin}},\qquad
 AK=0,\qquad
 \Cop^*=-\frac12\Ptr K,\qquad
 \Cop K=\Box,
\]
\[
 A+\frac12\Cop^*\Cop
           =\Pgr=-\frac14\Ptr\Box.
\]
The free action is
\[
 I_{\mathrm{free}}
 =\frac12\pair r{Ar}
       -\frac12\pair\phi{(\Box+m^2)\phi}
       +\int(b\cdot\Cop r-b^2-\bar c\cdot\Box c)\dd^4x.
\]

\begin{proposition}[Exact recovery and its necessary qualification]
\label{prop:recovery}
The classical structure in X-J-ST is exactly
\eqref{eq:SI}; hence it agrees with X-I-ST at every
retained order and with X-H-ST through order two.

At \(\kappa=0\) its field differential is \(s_0\).
Its complete BV Hamiltonian has
\[
 [\kappa^0]I=I_{\mathrm{free}}+\pair r{Ah}.
\]
It is the free BV Hamiltonian in the centered sector
\(h=k=0\), and more generally whenever \(Ah=0\).
An arbitrary off-shell background tadpole is not
removed by taking \(\kappa=0\).

Setting \(\lambda=0\) removes only the additional
quartic interaction; it does not remove all reference
Einstein--scalar interactions.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
There is no action modification after \eqref{eq:SI}.
At order zero, the gravitational quadratic coefficient
minus its background-only contribution is
\[
 \frac12\pair{h+r}{A(h+r)}
                       -\frac12\pair h{Ah}
       =\frac12\pair r{Ar}+\pair r{Ah}.
\]
The other zero-order terms are those displayed in
\(I_{\mathrm{free}}\).
The field-limit and coupling statements follow directly
from \eqref{eq:smetric}--\eqref{eq:SI}.
\end{proof}

The normalized free causal BRST theorem remains the
X-G-ST theorem on the declared Minkowski completion
\cite{XGST}. No interacting causal carrier is inferred
from Proposition~\ref{prop:retainedCME}.
A direct non-descent check is given in
Section~\ref{sec:diagnostics}.

%=====================================================================
\section{Section A: two action-derived compact charged coefficients}
\label{sec:coefficients}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{Finite polarization of the retained vertex}

The open set \(\{a>0\}\) is nonempty. Choose two disjoint
relatively compact balls in this set and nonzero
nonnegative functions
\[
 u_i\in C_c^\infty(U),\qquad i=1,2,
\]
supported in those balls. Define
\begin{equation}
 M_i=\int a u_i^3\dd^4x>0,\qquad
 w_i=\frac{a u_i^3}{M_i},\qquad
 \int w_i\dd^4x=1.
 \label{eq:weights}
\end{equation}
Their supports \(K_i=\supp w_i\) are disjoint.
All choices occur inside the already fixed plateau.

Freeze the calibration scalar
\(\phi_{\mathrm{cal}}(x)=x^1\). It is an off-shell
smooth function, not an assumed solution.

\begin{definition}[The two coefficients]
\label{def:coefficients}
For \(i=1,2\), set
\begin{align}
 P_i[\phi]
  &=3!\,[z^3][\kappa^3]\,
       \partial_\lambda
       \Stilde[r,\phi+zu_i,c,\bar c,b,\Phi^*],
 \label{eq:polarization}\\
 \mathcal C_i[\phi]
  &=\frac{P_i[\phi]-P_i[\phi_{\mathrm{cal}}]}{M_i}.
 \label{eq:Ci}
\end{align}
Their order-labelled diagnostic insertions are
\[
 \mathcal O_i(\kappa)=\kappa^3\mathcal C_i.
\]
These insertions are not added to the action.
\end{definition}

\begin{theorem}[Explicit second coefficient]
\label{thm:coefficient}
The definition gives
\begin{equation}
 P_i[\phi]=\int a u_i^3\phi\,\dd^4x,\qquad
 \mathcal C_i[\phi]
       =\int w_i(\phi-x^1)\dd^4x.
 \label{eq:moment}
\end{equation}
In particular, \(\Csecond\) is a compact, continuous,
ghost-number-zero scalar functional defined by finite
Taylor extraction from the X-I-ST interaction.

The two functionals are linearly independent modulo
constants. No distributional product, Green operator,
or \(\hbar\)-dependent coefficient is used.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
The coupling derivative and order extraction in
\eqref{eq:polarization} leave \(V_a\).
The coefficient of \(z^3\) in
\[
 \frac1{24}\int a(\phi+zu_i)^4\dd^4x
\]
is \(\int a\phi u_i^3\dd^4x/6\).
Multiplication by \(3!\) proves \eqref{eq:moment}.

Smooth compact weights give continuity in the
compact-open smooth topology.
Choose a test variation equal to one near \(K_1\)
and zero near \(K_2\); the derivative vector of
\((\Cfirst,\Csecond)\) is then \((1,0)\).
Interchanging the supports gives \((0,1)\), proving
independence.
\end{proof}

The profile \(u_i\) is a fixed polarization direction.
It is not a new dynamical field, compensator, or
spurion. The calibration subtraction is fixed
classical data and does not create invariance.

\subsection{The charges and the formal-order correction}

\begin{proposition}[Charge identity]
\label{prop:charge}
For every \(\xi\in\grel\),
\begin{equation}
 q_i(\phi;\xi)
   :=q_{\mathcal C_i}(\phi;\xi)
    =\int w_i\xi^\mu\partial_\mu\phi\,\dd^4x.
 \label{eq:qi}
\end{equation}
On scalar functionals the retained BV differential gives
\begin{equation}
 \QI\mathcal C_i
        =\kappa\Jcharge_i[\phi,c],\qquad
 \Jcharge_i[\phi,c]
        =\int w_i c^\mu\partial_\mu\phi\,\dd^4x.
 \label{eq:BRSTcharge}
\end{equation}
The polynomial field rule also gives exactly
\begin{equation}
 s\mathcal O_i=\kappa^4\Jcharge_i.
 \label{eq:weightedcharge}
\end{equation}
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
Differentiate the scalar pullback and use
\eqref{eq:moment}. For the BV action, only the
scalar antifield coupling acts on \(\mathcal C_i\);
its rule is \eqref{eq:sscalar}.
The calibration scalar is not varied.
Multiplication by \(\kappa^3\) gives
\eqref{eq:weightedcharge}.
\end{proof}

\statementbox{Charge versus retained formal order}{%
The coefficient \(\mathcal C_i\) is charged:
its first scalar BRST variation is
\(\kappa\Jcharge_i\).

The order-labelled insertion
\(\kappa^3\mathcal C_i\) has its first variation at
order four. It is therefore closed \emph{modulo}
\(\kappa^4\), but that truncated zero is not an
exact invariance theorem.

No real nonzero number is substituted for a
nilpotent element of \(R_3\).}

\subsection{Exact local charges and independent values}

Choose \(t_*>0\) small enough that the compact swept sets
\[
 K_i+[-2t_*,2t_*]e_1
\]
lie in disjoint open subsets of \(U\).
Here \(e_1\) is the coordinate vector in the \(x^1\)
direction. Choose smooth compact cutoffs \(\chi_i,\eta_i\)
with disjoint supports for different \(i\), such that
both equal one near these swept sets and
\(\supp\eta_i\subset\{\chi_i=1\}\).
Set
\begin{equation}
 \xi_i=\eta_i\partial_1,\qquad
 \xi=\xi_1+\xi_2,\qquad
 \phi_{\mathbf b}
       =x^1+b_1\chi_1+b_2\chi_2,
       \quad \mathbf b=(b_1,b_2)\in\RR^2.
 \label{eq:witnessfamily}
\end{equation}

\begin{theorem}[Independent second charge and local matching]
\label{thm:localmatching}
The family \eqref{eq:witnessfamily} satisfies
\begin{equation}
 \mathcal C_i[\phi_{\mathbf b}]=b_i,\qquad
 q_i(\phi_{\mathbf b};\xi_j)=\delta_{ij}.
 \label{eq:chargematrix}
\end{equation}
For \(|t|<t_*\), its scalar-flow comparisons obey
\begin{align}
 \mathcal C_j[\phi_{\mathbf b}\circ F_t^{\xi_i}]
                       &=b_j+\delta_{ij}t,
 \label{eq:independentflow}\\
 \mathcal C_i[\phi_{\mathbf b}\circ F_t^\xi]
                       &=b_i+t.
 \label{eq:commonflow}
\end{align}
Consequently
\[
 I_{\mathrm{loc}}=\Csecond-\Cfirst
\]
is invariant on the specified common-flow comparisons.

In particular, the second value can be changed while
the first is fixed, and the second charge is not obtained
by assigning a compensating number to the first.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
On \(K_i\), the cutoffs have
\(\chi_i=\eta_i=1\), the other cutoffs vanish, and
\(\partial_1\phi_{\mathbf b}=1\).
Equations \eqref{eq:moment} and \eqref{eq:qi} prove
\eqref{eq:chargematrix}.

A flow trajectory starting in \(K_i\), for
\(|t|<t_*\), remains in the region where the relevant
vector field equals \(\partial_1\).
Thus it is exactly \(x\mapsto x+te_1\).
The scalar along that trajectory is
\(x^1+t+b_i\).
The other supported vector field vanishes there.
Integration against \(w_i\) gives
\eqref{eq:independentflow}--\eqref{eq:commonflow}.
The difference cancels the common \(t\).
\end{proof}

These are off-shell scalar comparisons on a fixed
coordinate patch. They are not a claim that the family
solves an interacting Euler system or is a homogeneous
free ghost configuration. Infinitesimally they are
precisely the scalar directions occurring in
\eqref{eq:sscalar}; their formal gauge parameter in
that rule carries its explicit factor of \(\kappa\).

\subsection{The whole-algebra matching failure}

\begin{theorem}[One matched direction is not whole-algebra closure]
\label{thm:wholealgebra}
The difference \(I_{\mathrm{loc}}\) is not invariant
under all directions of \(\grel\).
Indeed,
\[
 q_{I_{\mathrm{loc}}}(\phi_{\mathbf b};\xi_2)=1.
\]

More generally, if a \(C^1\) function
\(F:\RR^2\to V\), with finite-dimensional real target
\(V\), has zero variation under every relative direction
at every \(\phi_{\mathbf b}\), then \(F\) is constant.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
The first assertion follows from
\eqref{eq:chargematrix}.
For the second, the two directions give
\[
 \partial_{b_1}F(\mathbf b)=0,\qquad
 \partial_{b_2}F(\mathbf b)=0.
\]
The connectedness of \(\RR^2\) proves constancy.
\end{proof}

For any proposed linear combination
\(\rho\,\Cfirst-\gamma\,\Csecond\), whole-algebra
first-order matching would require
\[
 \rho\,q_1(\phi;\zeta)-\gamma\,q_2(\phi;\zeta)=0
                  \qquad(\zeta\in\grel).
\]
The rank-two matrix \eqref{eq:chargematrix} excludes
a nonzero constant pair \((\rho,\gamma)\) on this family.

This is the exact additional matching issue separated
in X-Enter-ST \cite{XEnterST}. It is not solved by a
positive TV gap.

%=====================================================================
\section{Finite dictionaries and a supplied-data interface}
\label{sec:dictionary}
%=====================================================================

\begin{definition}[Admissible second-coefficient task]
\label{def:task}
A task specifies:
\begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\roman*)}]
\item the functional \(\mathcal C_i\), a charge
\(q_i(\phi;\xi)\), or a specified real coefficient
of \(\Jcharge_i\);
\item all compact profiles, polarization directions,
calibration data, and smooth evaluation data;
\item for odd expressions, a finite exterior algebra
and a specified ordered real coefficient extraction;
\item a supplied value or a justified numerical enclosure;
\item a fixed finite encoding and output boundary.
\end{enumerate}
A report dictionary is a finite collection of such tasks.
\end{definition}

For example, on \(\phi_{\mathbf b}\) and the ghost
\(c=\vartheta\xi_2\),
\[
 \mathcal C_2=b_2,\qquad
 [\vartheta]\mathcal J_2=1,\qquad
 [\vartheta]\mathcal J_1=0.
\]
These are exact analytical tasks. No Grassmann-valued
quantity is interpreted as an ordered physical outcome.

\begin{proposition}[Finiteness and continuity]
Every admissible task is a finite real number and is
continuous in the supplied smooth data on compact
supports. Every finite task collection admits a finite
report alphabet.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
The moments are compact linear integrals.
The charges are compact first-jet integrals.
Finite exterior expansion produces finitely many
ordinary real integrals.
Compact smooth seminorm estimates prove continuity.
A finite experiment returns a finite list of labels,
outcomes, flags, and permitted status words.
\end{proof}

This is not an algorithm for evaluating arbitrary smooth
descriptions. Exact real control parameters, when used,
are supplied ideal mathematical controls. Approximation
errors and finite numerical descriptions are charged
separately.

A finite dictionary is also not a finite-dimensional
classification of all continuum residuals.

\subsection{A common comparison interface}

In any comparison of zero and nonzero coefficients:
\begin{itemize}
\item the task label, clock law, gain, scale, instrument,
and failure rule are the same;
\item the reported task label does not contain the
hypothesis or the unknown tested value;
\item auxiliary and reference preparations are matched
as specified;
\item only the supplied amplitude value changes.
\end{itemize}
Thus the positive gap below is not created by attaching
different classical hypothesis labels to otherwise
identical experiments.

%=====================================================================
\section{Section B: selective amplitude visibility}
\label{sec:amplitude}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{The retained amplitude family}

For \(\sigma>0\), set
\begin{equation}
 p(z)=\frac{1+\tanh(z/\sigma)}2,\qquad
 \ket{e_\sigma(z)}
       =\sqrt{1-p(z)}\ket0+\sqrt{p(z)}\ket1,
 \qquad
 \tau_\sigma(z)=\proj{e_\sigma(z)}.
 \label{eq:amplitude}
\end{equation}
The scale \(\sigma\) has the units of \(z\).

Let
\[
 D=\proj1-\proj0,\qquad
 X=\kb01+\kb10,\qquad
 t(z)=\tanh(z/\sigma),\qquad
 s(z)=\sech(z/\sigma).
\]
Then
\begin{equation}
 \tau_\sigma(z)
       =\frac12(I+t(z)D+s(z)X).
 \label{eq:bloch}
\end{equation}

This is the amplitude family of X-Enter/X-Enter-ST,
used here with the separately constructed coefficient
\cite{XEnter,XEnterST}. Its input is a supplied finite
encoding, not an unknown continuum field.

\begin{definition}[Selective instrument convention]
A finite instrument \(\{\Phi_y\}_{y\in Y}\) consists of
completely positive maps with trace-preserving sum.
Its complete recorded output is
\[
 \mathfrak R_\Phi(Z)
       =\sum_y\proj y_R\otimes\Phi_y(Z).
\]
Every \(\Phi_y(Z)\) is retained subnormalized.
\end{definition}

The output space of each block includes every declared
surviving quantum register. A fixed auxiliary preparation
may be incorporated into \(\Phi_y\). Reference extension
means tensoring the actual maps with an identity, not
assuming equality of unrelated reference preparations.

Put
\[
 A_y=\Phi_y(I/2),\qquad
 B_y=\Phi_y(D/2),\qquad
 C_y=\Phi_y(X/2).
\]
Linearity gives the exact formula
\begin{equation}
 \Phi_y(\tau_\sigma(z))=A_y+B_yt(z)+C_ys(z).
 \label{eq:selective}
\end{equation}

\begin{theorem}[Selective visibility or erasure]
\label{thm:amplitude}
For a fixed instrument and fixed \(\sigma\), its complete
output on \(\tau_\sigma(z)\) is constant on a nonempty
open interval containing zero if and only if
\[
 B_y=C_y=0\qquad(y\in Y).
\]
In that case it is constant on the entire declared
real-amplitude family.

For the classical law alone, the corresponding condition is
\[
 \tr B_y=\tr C_y=0\qquad(y\in Y).
\]
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Differentiate \eqref{eq:selective}:
\[
 \frac{\dd}{\dd z}\Phi_y(\tau_\sigma(z))
       =\frac1{\sigma}(B_ys(z)^2-C_ys(z)t(z)).
\]
At zero, constancy forces \(B_y=0\).
At any nonzero point in the interval,
\(s(z)t(z)\ne0\), so \(C_y=0\).
The converse follows from the exact formula.
Distinct classical blocks cannot cancel.
Taking traces gives the outcome-law statement.
\end{proof}

Erasure on this family is not necessarily a replacement
channel on all qubit states. It says nothing about a
Bloch direction that never occurs in \eqref{eq:bloch}.

\subsection{A higher-order encoding test}

The formal interaction label \(\kappa\) is not a real
preparation parameter. Introduce a separate real
small-signal parameter \(g\) for the following encoding
test.

\begin{theorem}[Retained-order visibility test]
\label{thm:secondorder}
Fix the instrument and scale. Let \(N\ge1\) and
\(q\ne0\), and suppose, for each fixed real \(\ell\),
\[
 z(g,\ell)=g^N\ell q+O(g^{N+1}).
\]
If
\[
 \mathfrak R_\Phi(\tau_\sigma(z(g,\ell)))
       -\mathfrak R_\Phi(\tau_\sigma(0))
                           =O(g^{2N+1})
\]
in trace norm for every fixed \(\ell\), then
\(B_y=C_y=0\) for all \(y\).

In particular, for the third-order-labelled coefficient,
\(N=3\), absence of response through the sixth encoding
order forces erasure of this whole amplitude family.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
The leading order in each block is
\[
 g^N\frac{\ell q}{\sigma}B_y+O(g^{N+1}),
\]
so a nonzero fixed \(\ell\) forces \(B_y=0\).
After that exact matrix vanishes, the leading term is
\[
 -g^{2N}\frac{\ell^2q^2}{2\sigma^2}C_y
                               +O(g^{2N+1}),
\]
using \(\sech u=1-u^2/2+O(u^4)\).
This forces \(C_y=0\).
\end{proof}

This strengthens the use of the predecessor's
second-order diagnostic by explicitly distinguishing
the order of the interaction from the order of its
encoding response \cite{XEnterST}. It is not a
sixth-order field-theoretic calculation.

For example, Hadamard followed by destructive readout has
\[
 \Pr(1\mid z)=\frac{1-\sech(z/\sigma)}2
                =\frac{z^2}{4\sigma^2}+O(z^4).
\]
A vanishing first derivative does not imply erasure.
If \(z=g^3d\), this effect first appears at order \(g^6\).

\subsection{General outcome-law discrepancy}

Write
\(\beta_y=\tr B_y\) and \(\gamma_y=\tr C_y\).
For every fixed instrument,
\begin{equation}
 \TV(P_z,P_0)
 =\frac12\sum_y
       \left|\beta_y\tanh(z/\sigma)
             +\gamma_y(\sech(z/\sigma)-1)\right|.
 \label{eq:generalTV}
\end{equation}
An endpoint equality can occur by cancellation, even
when the instrument is not constant on the whole family.
Thus positivity will be proved for a named instrument,
not inferred for every readout.

%=====================================================================
\section{Section C: complete destructive instruments and the positive gap}
\label{sec:instrument}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{A failure-retaining amplitude instrument}

Let \(Q\cong\CC^2\) be the signal register, and let
\(A_{\mathrm{fin}}\) contain every unmeasured finite
system. Fix \(0\le r\le1\). On operators on
\(Q\otimes A_{\mathrm{fin}}\), define
\begin{align}
 \mathcal M_+(Z)
   &=(1-r)(\bra1\otimes I)Z(\ket1\otimes I),
 \label{eq:Mplus}\\
 \mathcal M_-(Z)
   &=(1-r)(\bra0\otimes I)Z(\ket0\otimes I),
 \label{eq:Mminus}\\
 \mathcal M_F(Z)&=r\,\Tr_QZ.
 \label{eq:MF}
\end{align}
The complete output is
\[
 \mathcal M(Z)=\sum_{y\in\{F,+,-\}}
                         \proj y_R\otimes\mathcal M_y(Z).
\]
The failure branch is retained. Its two internal
destructive outcomes are summed, not postselected.
No raw failure bit is exported at this declared boundary.

\begin{theorem}[Complete signal instrument]
\label{thm:signal}
The instrument \eqref{eq:Mplus}--\eqref{eq:MF} is complete.
It satisfies, for every operator and every untouched reference
\(E\),
\begin{equation}
 \Tr_R[(\mathcal M\otimes\id_E)(Z)]=\Tr_QZ.
 \label{eq:signaldrop}
\end{equation}
The measured signal name \(Q\) is consumed. The quantum
output consists of \(A_{\mathrm{fin}}\), with its
conditional reference correlations.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
The Kraus maps are
\[
 \sqrt{1-r}(\bra1\otimes I),\quad
 \sqrt{1-r}(\bra0\otimes I),\quad
 \sqrt r(\bra0\otimes I),\quad
 \sqrt r(\bra1\otimes I),
\]
with the last two assigned the common outcome \(F\).
Their adjoint products sum to the identity.
Their sum after discarding the record is the partial
trace over \(Q\).
Both statements remain true after tensoring with \(I_E\).
The output types give consumption.
\end{proof}

A finite realization prepares an independent binary
failure flag, destructively reads it, and consumes the
signal in either branch. Coarse-graining the two failure
outcomes is a channel specification. If a larger
accessible apparatus exports those outcomes, that larger
boundary must be compared separately.

\subsection{Exact positive gap}

Use the same spectator preparation
\(\rho_{A_{\mathrm{fin}}E}\) in both hypotheses, and supply
\[
 \tau_\sigma(\nu d)_Q\otimes\rho_{A_{\mathrm{fin}}E},
\]
where \(\nu\in\RR\) is a fixed classical report gain.

\begin{theorem}[Positive selective TV gap]
\label{thm:TV}
The complete classical law is
\[
 P_d(F)=r,\qquad
 P_d(\pm)=\frac{1-r}{2}
               \left(1\pm\tanh(\nu d/\sigma)\right).
\]
Its distance from the zero-coefficient law is exactly
\begin{equation}
 \Delta(d):=\TV(P_d,P_0)
       =\frac{1-r}{2}
                    |\tanh(\nu d/\sigma)|.
 \label{eq:TV}
\end{equation}
The complete output states, retaining the matched spectator
and reference, also have trace distance \(\Delta(d)\).

The gap is positive if and only if
\(r<1\) and \(\nu d\ne0\).
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Apply the branch maps to the product input.
The spectator factor is the same in every branch.
The failure probability is unchanged.
The two successful probabilities differ from their
zero values by opposite quantities of magnitude
\((1-r)|\tanh(\nu d/\sigma)|/2\).
Summing their absolute differences and dividing by two
gives \eqref{eq:TV}.

For the complete outputs, orthogonality of the classical
blocks makes the trace norm the sum of the block norms.
The common normalized spectator factor has trace norm one,
so the same expression results.
\end{proof}

The theorem compares specified supplied encodings.
It does not claim a gap for arbitrary unrelated
coefficient-dependent reference preparations, arbitrary
faults, or an instrument that erases the signal.

One may choose \(\nu=g^3\) to display the interaction-order
label in the report calibration. Then, for fixed \(d\),
\[
 \Delta_g(d)
       =\frac{1-r}{2}|\tanh(g^3d/\sigma)|
       =\frac{1-r}{2\sigma}|g|^3|d|+O(|g|^9).
\]
This is an exact finite-state encoding of a chosen
monomial, not an evaluation of \(R_3\) at a nonzero real
\(\kappa\), nor a controlled remainder for full field dynamics.

\subsection{An exact finite calibration instance}

\begin{corollary}[A gap of \(3/16\)]
\label{cor:benchmark}
Take
\[
 \nu=1,\qquad r=\frac14,\qquad
 d=\frac{\sigma}{2}\log3,
\]
and evaluate \(\Csecond\) on \(\phi_{(0,d)}\).
The signal state and laws are
\[
 \ket{e_\sigma(d)}
      =\frac12\ket0+\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\ket1,
\]
\[
 (P_d(F),P_d(+),P_d(-))
       =\left(\frac14,\frac9{16},\frac3{16}\right),
 \qquad
 (P_0(F),P_0(+),P_0(-))
       =\left(\frac14,\frac38,\frac38\right).
\]
Consequently \(\Delta(d)=3/16\).
\end{corollary}

\begin{proof}
The coefficient is \(d\) by
Theorem~\ref{thm:localmatching}.
Since \(\tanh((\log3)/2)=1/2\), substitution proves
every displayed equality.
\end{proof}

This is an analytical calibration certificate.
It does not assert a laboratory realization or a
numerical run.

\subsection{Finite dictionary and complete references}

Let a task register \(J\) have a fixed orthonormal basis
\(\ket j\), and let \(\pi_j\) be fixed task probabilities.
For each valid task choose supplied values \(d_j\),
scales \(\sigma_j>0\), failure probabilities \(r_j\),
and gains \(\nu_j\).
Prepare
\begin{equation}
 \Omega_{\mathbf d}
 =\sum_j\pi_j\proj j_J\otimes
      \tau_{\sigma_j}(\nu_jd_j)_Q
                      \otimes\rho_{A_{\mathrm{fin}}E,j}.
 \label{eq:dictionaryinput}
\end{equation}
All \(\pi_j\) and spectator preparations are identical
in the zero comparison. The task labels are retained.

\begin{theorem}[Positive TV gap on a finite dictionary]
\label{thm:dictionaryTV}
A controlled use of the signal instrument gives a complete
instrument on every \(JQ A_{\mathrm{fin}}\) operator.
For the preparations \eqref{eq:dictionaryinput},
\begin{equation}
 \TV(P_{\mathbf d},P_{\mathbf0})
 =\sum_j\pi_j\frac{1-r_j}{2}
                 |\tanh(\nu_jd_j/\sigma_j)|.
 \label{eq:dictionaryTV}
\end{equation}
The corresponding complete output trace distance,
including \(A_{\mathrm{fin}}E\), is the same.

The gap is positive exactly when at least one retained
task has
\(\pi_j>0\), \(r_j<1\), and \(\nu_jd_j\ne0\).
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Destructively read \(J\), then apply the instrument
selected by its classical code.
The Kraus maps are tensor products of \(\bra j_J\)
with the branch maps in Theorem~\ref{thm:signal}.
Completeness follows by summing first the branch maps
and then the orthogonal task projectors.

For the declared inputs, different \(j\)-blocks are
orthogonal. Their trace norms add, and
Theorem~\ref{thm:TV} applies in each block.
\end{proof}

For a non-power-of-two dictionary, pad the task register.
An unused code returns an explicit invalid-task flag and
still consumes its signal input. No probability is dropped.

Retaining the task label matters. If it is forgotten,
opposite signed successful-probability changes from two
tasks can cancel.

\subsection{The complete finite clock}

Let \(C\cong\CC^{2^q}\) have a calibrated orthonormal
basis \(\{\ket{\tau_k}\}\), and let \(B_C\ket{\tau_k}=\ket k\).
For an arbitrary surviving interface \(A\), define
\[
 D_k=\bra{\tau_k}_C\otimes I_A,
 \qquad
 \mathcal T_C(Z)
       =\sum_k\proj k_{R_C}\otimes D_kZD_k^\dagger.
\]

\begin{theorem}[Destructive clock and combined instrument]
\label{thm:clock}
The clock channel is CPTP and, with every reference,
\[
 \Tr_{R_C}[(\mathcal T_C\otimes\id_E)(Z)]
                                              =\Tr_CZ.
\]
Composing it with the task-and-signal instrument gives
a complete finite instrument. If all its records are
discarded and the intervening operations act only on
the consumed clock, task, and signal factors, the
surviving output is their joint partial trace.

Clock, task, and measured signal names are not quantum
outputs of that instrument.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
The clock Kraus maps are \(\ket k_{R_C}\otimes D_k\).
Their adjoint products sum to the identity.
Clock-basis expansion proves the partial-trace identity.
Composition with Theorem~\ref{thm:dictionaryTV} proves
completeness; composing the displayed partial-trace
identities proves the final statement.
\end{proof}

This is the complete destructive clock mechanism of
I-B and En09-A \cite{IB,En09}. Conditional reference
states may be steered by selecting an outcome; the
unconditional reference marginal is unchanged.

Calibrated readings are finite history labels unless
a separate event-time correspondence is supplied.
No claim is made that several stochastic readings all
equal the coordinate time of one fixed event.

%=====================================================================
\section{An optional local relational phase package}
\label{sec:relational}
%=====================================================================

The independent coefficients also instantiate a restricted
two-coefficient comparison. This section does not replace
the direct amplitude theorem or strengthen local charge
matching to whole-algebra matching.

For \(\sigma_{\mathrm p}>0\), prepare
\begin{equation}
 \ket{\psi(b_1,b_2)}
   =\frac{\ket0+e^{i\alpha}\ket1}{\sqrt2}
      \otimes
      \frac{\ket0+e^{i\beta}\ket1}{\sqrt2},
 \qquad
 \alpha=\frac{b_1}{\sigma_{\mathrm p}},
 \quad
 \beta=\frac{b_2}{\sigma_{\mathrm p}}.
 \label{eq:phaseinput}
\end{equation}
Define
\[
 \ket{\chi_\pm}=\frac{\ket{01}\pm\ket{10}}{\sqrt2}.
\]
For input on the two signals and \(A_{\mathrm{fin}}\), put
\begin{align}
 \mathcal N_F(Z)
  &=(\bra{00}\otimes I)Z(\ket{00}\otimes I)
     +(\bra{11}\otimes I)Z(\ket{11}\otimes I), \notag\\
 \mathcal N_\pm(Z)
  &=(\bra{\chi_\pm}\otimes I)
                              Z(\ket{\chi_\pm}\otimes I).
 \label{eq:phaseinstrument}
\end{align}

\begin{theorem}[Complete common-charge phase instrument]
\label{thm:relational}
The maps \eqref{eq:phaseinstrument} form a complete
destructive instrument.
For every \(\gamma\in\RR\), let
\[
 G_\gamma=\diag(1,e^{i\gamma})
                         \otimes\diag(1,e^{i\gamma}).
\]
Then
\begin{equation}
 \mathcal N_y\circ\Ad_{G_\gamma\otimes I}
                      =\mathcal N_y,\qquad y=F,+,-,
 \label{eq:phasecovariance}
\end{equation}
on all operators and with arbitrary untouched references.

On \eqref{eq:phaseinput},
\[
 P(F)=\frac12,\qquad
 P(\pm)=\frac{1\pm\cos\theta}{4},
 \qquad
 \theta=\frac{b_2-b_1}{\sigma_{\mathrm p}}.
\]
For fixed \(b_1\), comparison of \(b_2=b_1+d\) with
\(b_2=b_1\) has
\begin{equation}
 \TV(P_d,P_0)=\frac{1-\cos(d/\sigma_{\mathrm p})}{4}.
 \label{eq:phaseTV}
\end{equation}
It is positive unless \(d/\sigma_{\mathrm p}\in2\pi\mathbb Z\).
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
The two computational even-parity projectors and the
two odd Bell projectors sum to the identity.
Each Kraus bra in the failure sum acquires only a
scalar phase under \(G_\gamma\); each \(\chi_\pm\)
acquires the common phase \(e^{i\gamma}\).
Their selective maps are therefore unchanged.
Tensoring the operator identities with a reference
identity proves the complete version.

The odd-parity amplitudes are
\((e^{i\beta}\pm e^{i\alpha})/(2\sqrt2)\).
The even-parity total probability is \(1/2\).
These give the laws and their exact TV distance.
\end{proof}

A CNOT followed by Hadamard and destructive readout
implements the instrument, with the two even Bell
outcomes merged into \(F\).
No failure branch is removed \cite{XEnter,XEnterST}.

\begin{corollary}[Exact scope of the local relational interpretation]
On the common-flow family of
Theorem~\ref{thm:localmatching}, the encoded phases
both acquire \(t/\sigma_{\mathrm p}\).
The complete declared phase instrument is therefore
invariant under that comparison.

It is not whole-\(\grel\) invariant on the
two-coefficient family.
\end{corollary}

\begin{proof}
The common-flow assertion follows from
\eqref{eq:commonflow} and
\eqref{eq:phasecovariance}.
Under \(\xi_2\), only \(b_2\) changes, so the relative
phase and, generically, its cosine change.
\end{proof}

The phase readout sees a cosine, not an exact real
number. Evenness and periodicity produce aliases.
Furthermore, exporting the raw even Bell outcome would
enlarge the output boundary and can reveal
\(\alpha+\beta\), destroying collective-phase
invariance. The declared coarse failure map must not
be confused with a larger logged instrument.

%=====================================================================
\section{Selectivity, orbit bounds, and non-acquisition}
\label{sec:nonacquisition}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{The encoding-independent orbit statement}

\begin{proposition}[Transitive-orbit erasure bound]
\label{prop:orbit}
Let \(T:\RR\to\mathcal D\) take values in a metric
space \((\mathcal D,d)\).
If
\[
 T(z+t)=T(z)\qquad(z,t\in\RR),
\]
then \(T\) is constant.
If instead
\[
 \sup_{z,t\in\RR}d(T(z+t),T(z))\le\eta,
\]
then the diameter of its image is at most \(\eta\).
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
For any \(z,z'\), take \(t=z'-z\).
\end{proof}

This argument requires neither a qubit encoding nor
informational completeness. It is the elementary
transitive-orbit mechanism used in the predecessor
\cite{XEnterST}.

The earlier convolution coefficient has its own
whole-orbit contract. The local scalar flows in
Theorem~\ref{thm:localmatching} are not substituted for
that contract. A bounded comparison interval does not
become a full real gauge orbit merely by being called
an orbit.

The positive amplitude gap detects dependence on a
charged coefficient. It does not make that dependence
gauge invariant.

\subsection{Positive visibility does not mean informational completeness}

\begin{proposition}[Explicit incompleteness]
\label{prop:incomplete}
The direct amplitude report is not informationally
complete for arbitrary qubit inputs.
Even the direct and Hadamard report settings together
are not informationally complete for arbitrary qubits.

The entire present coefficient package is also not
informationally complete for the continuum scalar field.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
The direct effects lie in
\(\operatorname{span}\{I,D\}\), so, for example,
\(\proj+\) and \(\proj-\) have the same direct law.
Adding the Hadamard setting gives effects in
\(\operatorname{span}\{I,D,X\}\).
The distinct states
\((I+Y)/2\) and \((I-Y)/2\) still have the same laws.

For the field claim choose a nonzero
\(v\in C_c^\infty(U\setminus(K_1\cup K_2))\).
For every \(\phi\) and every real \(t\),
\[
 \mathcal C_i[\phi+tv]=\mathcal C_i[\phi].
\]
All encodings depending only on these two values
therefore agree on infinitely many distinct fields.
\end{proof}

On the particular one-parameter family
\(\tau_\sigma(z)\), the direct probability is injective
in \(z\). This narrower statistical identifiability
does not contradict Proposition~\ref{prop:incomplete};
it does not reconstruct arbitrary states or fields.

\subsection{What is actually measured}

\begin{proposition}[The instrument is not a field-acquisition map]
\label{prop:noacquisition}
The signal instrument measures effects of the supplied
finite signal register. It does not acquire
\(\mathcal C_2[\phi]\) from an unknown continuum field.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
Its signal effects are
\[
 E_F=rI,\qquad
 E_+=(1-r)\proj1,\qquad
 E_-=(1-r)\proj0.
\]
Their pullbacks act on \(Q\), not on a field
configuration space or a field representation.
The coefficient enters only through the separately
supplied preparation \(\tau_\sigma(\nu d)\).

No field--apparatus coupling, physical representation
of the classical functional, or continuum-to-register
channel has been defined.
\end{proof}

The same limitation applies to the phase preparation.
Its finite two-qubit realization supplies no coherent
acquisition of the two continuum moments.

%=====================================================================
\section{Errors, finite composition, locality, and transport}
\label{sec:composition}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{Input precision and robust positive margins}

Use the conventions
\[
 \dtr(\rho,\sigma)=\frac12\norm{\rho-\sigma}_1,
 \qquad
 \ddia(\Phi,\Psi)=\frac12\norm{\Phi-\Psi}_\diamond.
\]

\begin{lemma}[Lipschitz amplitude preparation]
\label{lem:lipschitz}
For all real \(z,z'\),
\[
 \dtr(\tau_\sigma(z),\tau_\sigma(z'))
                         \le\frac{|z-z'|}{2\sigma}.
\]
\end{lemma}

\begin{proof}
The Bloch vector is \((s(z),0,t(z))\), whose derivative
has Euclidean norm
\[
 \frac1{\sigma}
       \sqrt{s(z)^2t(z)^2+s(z)^4}
       =\frac{s(z)}{\sigma}\le\frac1{\sigma}.
\]
Trace distance of qubit states is half the Euclidean
distance of their Bloch vectors.
Integrate the derivative bound.
\end{proof}

\begin{theorem}[Robust selective certificate]
\label{thm:robust}
Suppose the two complete implemented comparisons have
trace-distance errors at most \(e_d,e_0\) relative to
the complete ideal outputs of Theorem~\ref{thm:TV}.
Their actual record gap satisfies
\begin{equation}
 \TV(\widetilde P_d,\widetilde P_0)
       \ge\max\{0,\Delta(d)-e_d-e_0\}.
 \label{eq:robustTV}
\end{equation}

If a positive task value is certified by
\(d\in[L,U]\), \(L>0\), and the declared parameter
bounds give
\[
 r\le r_{\max}<1,\qquad
 |\nu|\ge\nu_{\min}>0,\qquad
 \sigma\le\sigma_{\max},
\]
then
\begin{equation}
 \Delta(d)\ge
 \frac{1-r_{\max}}2
           \tanh\!\left(\frac{\nu_{\min}L}{\sigma_{\max}}\right)>0.
 \label{eq:enclosuregap}
\end{equation}
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Taking a record marginal is trace-distance contractive.
Apply the reverse triangle inequality through the two
ideal laws.
The second result follows from monotonicity of
\(\tanh\) on nonnegative arguments.
\end{proof}

A supplied-value approximation
\(|d-\tilde d|\le\epsilon_d\) contributes at most
\(|\nu|\epsilon_d/(2\sigma)\) to the preparation
distance by Lemma~\ref{lem:lipschitz}.
A channel error does not validate a false enclosure.

These are complete-interface comparison statements
\cite{Watrous,XIST}. They do not assert a finite-sample
confidence level without an additional sampling model.

\subsection{Finite adaptive composition}

\begin{theorem}[Complete finite composition]
\label{thm:composition}
Any finite adaptive tree of the specified instruments,
allowed finite gates, allocations, and compatible
transports has complete path maps \(K_h\) satisfying
\[
 \Phi_y(Z)=\sum_{h:\,\mathrm{out}(h)=y}K_hZK_h^\dagger,
 \qquad
 \sum_hK_h^\dagger K_h=I.
\]
The identities hold with every untouched reference,
and every failure history is included.

Each destructive use consumes its input names.
A later quantum use requires a separately supplied
factor, including a new clock when needed.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Compose the allocation isometries, unitaries, and
destructive Kraus maps along each history.
Backward induction on the finite tree proves
completeness: each terminal identity is pulled back
through a complete instrument or an isometry.
Tensoring the path identities with the reference
identity proves the complete statement.
Input and output names enforce consumption.
\end{proof}

This is the finite complete-history mechanism of the
predecessors and the resource-certified programme
records \cite{XIST,XHST,En02B,En02C}.

Completeness is not itself a distinguishability
lower bound. An arbitrary later channel can erase
a positive gap.

\begin{corollary}[When a gap survives a continuation]
\label{cor:gapcontinuation}
If a continuation leaves the previously reported
task, success/failure, and outcome record unchanged,
the final joint output distance is at least the
corresponding gap in \eqref{eq:dictionaryTV}.
The identity report transport below preserves it.

If the record is discarded or overwritten, no such
general lower bound follows.
\end{corollary}

\begin{proof}
The retained record is a marginal of the final output,
so contraction bounds its distance by the final
joint distance.
For the negative statement, a replacement channel
erases every input dependence.
\end{proof}

For compatible complete implementations, telescoping
gives
\begin{equation}
 \ddia(\widetilde\Gamma,\Gamma)
 \le\min\left\{1,\,
 e_{\mathrm{prep}}+e_{\mathrm{table}}
   +\sum_j e_j+e_{\mathrm{decode}}\right\}.
 \label{eq:telescoping}
\end{equation}
Each \(e_j\) concerns the complete fixed interface of
one component. The estimate follows from channel
contraction and the triangle inequality \cite{Watrous}.
It does not prove exact causality of a faulty
implementation.

\subsection{Scheduled locality}

Let \(X_{\mathrm{site}}\) be a finite site set, with
finite site algebras. At tick \(s\), let the complete
channel factor over a declared partition \(\mathcal B_s\):
\[
 \Gamma_s=\bigotimes_{B\in\mathcal B_s}\Gamma_{s,B}.
\]
All records, selectors, control memories, reset wires,
and allocated workspace are included.
For output sites \(Y\), define
\[
 N_{t,t}(Y)=Y,\qquad
 N_{s,t}(Y)=
 \bigcup_{\substack{B\in\mathcal B_{s+1}\\
               B\cap N_{s+1,t}(Y)\ne\varnothing}}B.
\]

\begin{theorem}[Complete scheduled locality]
\label{thm:locality}
The network satisfies
\[
 (\Gamma_{s+1}^*\circ\cdots\circ\Gamma_t^*)(\Alg(Y))
                          \subseteq\Alg(N_{s,t}(Y)).
\]
Equal joint reductions on the ancestor input and an
untouched reference give equal joint output reductions.
A deterministic intervention outside the complete
backwards region cannot change that output.

If every dependency edge has a separately certified
future-causal regular host route, scheduled ancestry
is contained in the prescribed host causal relation.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
An excluded block acts on an identity factor in the
pulled-back observable. Its adjoint is unital.
A meeting block enlarges support only within itself.
Backward induction proves the inclusion.
Testing all output observables, including reference
observables, proves the reduction and intervention
claims. Concatenation of the supplied causal routes
proves the geometric statement.
\end{proof}

This is the I-B/En03-A/VII-E support mechanism
\cite{IB,En03,VIIE}. Scheduled ancestry is an upper
bound, not necessarily minimal influence or an entire
physical causal past. Scheduler consistency alone
does not reconstruct a Lorentz cone \cite{En08A}.

\subsection{Prescribed regular transport}

Choose a straight developed spatial segment of length
\(\ell>0\) inside the existing regular tube, and a
departure time \(t_{\mathrm d}\) after readout and its
declared buffers.
For \(n\ge1\), place equal payload registers
\(A_0,\ldots,A_n\) at equally spaced stations.
The payload includes the finite report and every
surviving quantum output required by the comparison.

Initialize \(A_1,\ldots,A_n\) in independent blanks
\(\omega\), and apply successive register SWAPs over
developed durations \(\ell/n\).

\begin{theorem}[Regular reference-preserving route]
\label{thm:route}
For every \(\rho_{A_0E}\), after hop \(j\) the state is
\[
 \rho_{A_jE}\otimes
       \bigotimes_{\substack{0\le i\le n\\i\ne j}}\omega_{A_i}.
\]
The logical payload channel is the identity including
all references. Arrival is at
\[
 t_{\mathrm d}+\ell,\qquad
 T_{\mathrm d}+\ell/c_{\mathrm h}.
\]
The entire route lies inside the retained regular tube.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
A SWAP transfers the complete payload, including its
reference correlations, into the next independent
blank and leaves the previous factor blank.
Induction proves the state formula.
Equal station spacing and developed duration give the
declared null cross-port displacement.
The time calibration gives the host arrival time.
\end{proof}

This is the target-adapted I-B/En08-B route
\cite{IB,En08B}. The SWAP permission is stroboscopic
finite control, not a derived microscopic relativistic
Hamiltonian. No exact-attainment theorem on an arbitrary
previously fixed lattice is asserted.

The route preserves existing correlations; it does not
establish gravity-generated entanglement.

\subsection{A finite resource ledger}

A \(p\)-qubit payload uses \(n\) register SWAPs and
\((n+1)p\) reserved route qubits.
The experiment additionally charges:
\begin{itemize}
\item every fresh clock and task register;
\item one supplied amplitude signal per direct trial,
or two supplied phase signals per relational trial;
\item the failure flag or equivalent finite ancilla;
\item every classical report reserve and lookup workspace;
\item source descriptions, numerical enclosures, supplier
storage, resets, durations, and buffers.
\end{itemize}
Untouched external references are listed separately;
their omission from laboratory operations does not
remove them from the complete comparison.

No repeated destructive trial is obtained by reusing
a consumed quantum name. Arbitrarily many trials require
an independently declared sequence of supplies and a
resource ledger for that sequence.

%=====================================================================
\section{Preserved diagnostics and explicit separations}
\label{sec:diagnostics}
%=====================================================================

\subsection{The earlier trees are not counted again}

The X-F-ST packet remains
\[
 \kappa^2
   \bigl(\mathcal T_{\mathrm{mat}}
       +\mathcal T_{\mathrm{mix}}
       +\mathcal T_{\mathrm{self}}\bigr).
\]
Its source normalization and its admission hypotheses
remain those of its source record \cite{XFST}.

\begin{proposition}[No action or lower-order interference]
\label{prop:noninterference}
X-J-ST modifies neither the classical action
\eqref{eq:SI} nor its equations.
The diagnostic insertions \(\kappa^3\mathcal C_i\)
are not extra action vertices or extra trees.

Consequently the retained tree packet, free Hessian,
free propagators, and predecessor free fish and
null-wavefront conditionals are unchanged.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
The only added constructions are coefficient extraction,
specified comparison data, and finite report channels.
None changes an action coefficient or a free numerical
distribution.
\end{proof}

A mathematical instrument on the supplied encoding does
not construct a graph containing quantum fields.

\subsection{The X-I-ST next residual is not canceled}

Let
\[
 \mathcal B_a
       =\frac16\int a\phi^3c^\mu\partial_\mu\phi\,\dd^4x.
\]
For the specified polynomial representative,
\begin{equation}
 \frac12(\Stilde,\Stilde)
 -\frac12(\widetilde{\mathcal S}_0,
                            \widetilde{\mathcal S}_0)
                  =\lambda\kappa^4\mathcal B_a.
 \label{eq:oldresidual}
\end{equation}
Indeed, the additional vertex has no antifields,
its self-bracket is zero, and its bracket with the
kinematic lift is \(sV_a=\kappa\mathcal B_a\).

No report channel modifies \eqref{eq:oldresidual}.
A supplied real coefficient of this odd residual is
a possible finite task, not a physical ghost observable.

\subsection{Free-shell non-descent remains}

For \(P_m=\Box+m^2\),
\[
 [P_m,c^\mu\partial_\mu]\phi
   =(\Box c^\mu)\partial_\mu\phi
      +2(\partial^\nu c^\mu)
                            \partial_\nu\partial_\mu\phi.
\]
With \(p>0\), \(\omega=\sqrt{p^2+m^2}\), choose
\[
 \phi_0=\cos(\omega t-px^1),\qquad
 c=\vartheta t\,\partial_1.
\]
Then \(P_m\phi_0=\Box c=0\), but
\[
 P_m(c^\mu\partial_\mu\phi_0)
    =2\vartheta p\omega\cos(\omega t-px^1)\ne0.
\]
Thus the natural positive-order scalar rule does not
preserve the unchanged free equation ideal.
A compact relative ghost equal to this coefficient
near a compact test supplies a local comparison, not
a global compact free ghost solution
\cite{XHST,XIST}.

X-J-ST supplies no retarded interacting BV transport
that would remove this distinction.

\subsection{Reciprocity remains a classical diagnostic}

The frozen X-G/X-G-ST source-switched metric operator
retains its separate witness
\[
 D_{\mathrm{recip}}
   =\frac{5M_\chi}{8}
        \int_0^\varepsilon
                \zeta(t)(\sigma_\varepsilon''(t))^2\dd t>0
\]
under its original support and free-input hypotheses
\cite{XG,XGST,XIST}.

Neither coefficient extraction nor a finite report
changes that operator.
The number is not \(\mathcal J_2\), not a master
residual, and not a loop anomaly.
Its exact source-preserving variational exclusion is
not a universal no-go for every changed classical
prescription.

\subsection{The convolution obstruction is unrepaired}

Retain the frozen convolution witness of
X-A-conv/X-A-conv-ST:
\[
 c_\varepsilon
  =\frac1{2N}\int\varrho_\varepsilon(z)
       \int(\psi(x)-\psi(x-z))^2\dd^4x\,\dd^4z>0.
\]
Its kernel, gauge algebra, Cauchy prescription, and
support certificates are unchanged
\cite{XConv,XConvST}.

There is no identification
\[
 \mathcal C_1=A_{\mathrm{conv}}
 \quad\text{or}\quad
 q_2=q_{\mathrm{conv}}
\]
in this paper.
In particular, the present construction does not
discharge X-Enter-ST's missing convolution reference
and whole-algebra matching hypothesis.

This refusal is not a nonexistence theorem for every
future reference. It states the absence of the needed
same-model identification here.

\subsection{Characteristic, quantum, and emergence boundaries}

The supplied XIV-H/I/J and XV-B records concern a
different characteristic composition and reconstruction
problem \cite{CharacteristicRecords}.
A finite classical moment and its TV gap do not provide
the missing full map, section, remainder, transverse
estimates, contact compatibility, output wavefront
theorem, or admitted characteristic coefficient.

Accordingly, no downstream quantum-admission or
interacting quantum Ward exit is opened.
The existence of technical manuscripts with those
identifiers is not denied.

The prepared-insertion restrictions of XVI-N and the
prescription-qualified XVI-O record are not changed
\cite{PreparedRecords}. No blanket statement across
other prescriptions is inferred.

The following remain explicit non-claims:
\begin{enumerate}
\item no full interacting quantum BRST differential;
\item no characteristic quantum coefficient or quantum
field product;
\item no loop-anomaly cancellation or ultraviolet completion;
\item no repair of the classical convolution obstruction;
\item no continuum acquisition of either coefficient;
\item no informational completeness of an orbit, a qubit,
or a continuum field;
\item no host derivation, Einstein dynamics from records,
or spacetime emergence.
\end{enumerate}

%=====================================================================
\section{Release and prospective significance}
\label{sec:release}
%=====================================================================

\begin{definition}[Local Grade S for X-J-ST]
\label{def:grade}
The release consists of:
\begin{enumerate}
\item the retained prescribed host, completion, positive
width, and finite operational reserve;
\item the two explicit compact coefficient definitions,
their charge witnesses, and their matching boundary;
\item a nonempty finite dictionary of supplied real tasks;
\item complete destructive instruments including failures,
surviving systems, and untouched references;
\item a positive scoped TV theorem and its error margins;
\item finite adaptive composition, scheduled locality,
a regular reference-preserving route, and resource accounting.
\end{enumerate}
Continuum field acquisition is not included in this grade.
\end{definition}

\begin{theorem}[X-J-ST mathematical release]
\label{thm:release}
Under Assumption~\ref{ass:host}:
\begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\roman*)}]
\item the second charged coefficient is the compact
ghost-number-zero scalar
\[
 \Csecond[\phi]=\int w_2(\phi-x^1)\dd^4x,
\]
obtained by the finite action polarization
\eqref{eq:polarization};
\item its value is independent of the first moment,
and the charge matrix is the identity on the declared
two-parameter comparison family;
\item a local common charge is realized exactly, while
whole-relative-algebra matching fails on an explicit
independent direction;
\item the selective amplitude instrument has the exact
positive gap \eqref{eq:TV}, with finite-dictionary
formula \eqref{eq:dictionaryTV} and the exact
\(3/16\) calibration instance;
\item the clock, signal, task, and optional phase
instruments are complete on arbitrary finite inputs
and all untouched references;
\item the higher-order encoding test and the robust
gap margins hold with their stated hypotheses;
\item finite adaptive composition, record-retaining
continuations, scheduled locality, and regular report
transport have the proved scopes;
\item the X-I-ST action is unchanged, its free-limit
qualification remains, and the earlier tree and
obstruction diagnostics are neither recounted nor repaired.
\end{enumerate}
This is a local Grade S selective coefficient package,
not a whole-algebra invariant convolution reference,
not quantum BRST, and not a characteristic coefficient.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Theorem~\ref{thm:coefficient} proves (i).
Theorem~\ref{thm:localmatching} proves (ii) and the
positive part of (iii);
Theorem~\ref{thm:wholealgebra} proves its boundary.
Theorems~\ref{thm:TV} and
\ref{thm:dictionaryTV}, with
Corollary~\ref{cor:benchmark}, prove (iv).
Theorems~\ref{thm:signal}, \ref{thm:clock},
and \ref{thm:relational} prove (v).
Theorems~\ref{thm:secondorder} and
\ref{thm:robust} prove (vi).
Theorem~\ref{thm:composition},
Corollary~\ref{cor:gapcontinuation},
and Theorems~\ref{thm:locality}--\ref{thm:route}
prove (vii).
Propositions~\ref{prop:recovery} and
\ref{prop:noninterference}, together with
Section~\ref{sec:diagnostics}, prove (viii).
\end{proof}

\begin{center}
\small
\renewcommand{\arraystretch}{1.12}
\begin{tabularx}{\linewidth}{@{}p{.33\linewidth}p{.22\linewidth}X@{}}
\toprule
Object & Verdict & Boundary\\
\midrule
Second compact scalar coefficient &
Constructed &
Finite polarization of the retained vertex\\
Independent values and charges &
Constructed &
Specified off-shell data\\
Local common-charge comparison &
Constructed &
Not whole-algebra matching\\
Positive amplitude TV gap &
Constructed &
Supplied encoding and fixed interface\\
Complete residual/reference instrument &
Constructed &
All declared branches retained\\
Continuum field acquisition &
Not constructed &
No field-to-register channel\\
Whole convolution reference &
Not constructed &
No same-model charge identification\\
Free/classical recovery &
Unchanged &
Centered free BV comparison qualified\\
Three-tree plateau &
Retained once &
No extra tree or action term\\
Convolution gap &
Unrepaired &
Frozen positive witness retained\\
Quantum characteristic admission &
Not established &
Separate analytic gates untouched\\
Spacetime emergence &
Not constructed &
Metric and causal dictionary prescribed\\
\bottomrule
\end{tabularx}
\end{center}

\subsection{What is new within this continuation}

The positive content is not merely a new label for an
assumed reference. The second coefficient has an
explicit action-derived formula, independent scalar
data, a nonzero compact charge, and a finite report
experiment with an exact distinguishability margin.

Equally important, the rank-two charge calculation
shows exactly why the local positive construction does
not become whole-algebra closure. The distinction
survives the complete-instrument audit; it cannot be
hidden by selecting a favorable outcome.

The prospective usefulness is as a calibration and
comparison module: later work can test a concrete
second coefficient, a finite preparation, and a complete
record interface without claiming that those operations
have acquired continuum data or defined a quantum
product. No general priority claim is made for
polarization, hyperbolic-tangent encodings, instruments,
or the classical BV method.

\subsection{What a stronger successor must supply}

A successor claiming the missing convolution application
must identify:
\begin{enumerate}
\item the first and second coefficients in the same
classical model and on the same domain;
\item the complete allowed gauge algebra and both charge
maps;
\item the required matching on that whole algebra;
\item any claimed equation-space descent;
\item the continuum-to-apparatus preparation or acquisition
map, if physical field measurement is claimed;
\item the complete instrument comparison, allowed changes,
errors, and resource budgets.
\end{enumerate}
None is supplied by a scalar TV gap alone.

%=====================================================================
\appendix
\section{Debugging and quantifier audit}
\label{app:debug}
%=====================================================================

\begin{longtable}{@{}p{.36\linewidth}p{.59\linewidth}@{}}
\toprule
Potential overstatement & Correction used here\\
\midrule
\endfirsthead
\toprule
Potential overstatement & Correction used here\\
\midrule
\endhead

``Second'' means the missing convolution reference &
The new second coefficient belongs to a named pair of
action-derived moments. No convolution identification
is asserted.\\[4pt]

A compensating number is an independent coefficient &
Independent variations and the rank-two charge matrix
are explicitly exhibited.\\[4pt]

Ghost number zero means uncharged &
Charge is defined as a specified scalar variation,
not ghost number or a conserved electrical charge.\\[4pt]

An order-three insertion has a visible charge in
\(\RR[\kappa]/(\kappa^4)\) &
Its first variation is order four. The coefficient is
charged, while the insertion is closed only at the
retained truncated order.\\[4pt]

Formal \(\kappa\) can be replaced by a real signal gain &
The encoding uses a separate real gain. No nonzero
real specialization of a nilpotent element is used.\\[4pt]

One matching direction proves full gauge invariance &
The independent direction \(\xi_2\) changes the
purported relational difference.\\[4pt]

Scalar comparison flows prove interacting solution
transport &
They are off-shell scalar comparisons. No Euler
solution or free-shell identification is claimed.\\[4pt]

A positive classical value gives a positive gap for
every instrument &
Visibility is proved for explicit named instruments.
Erasing instruments remain possible.\\[4pt]

A first-derivative test detects all dependence &
The Hadamard example has a nonzero quadratic response.
The encoding-level higher-order test is proved.\\[4pt]

A successful branch is the complete experiment &
Failure probability and every declared residual
are retained.\\[4pt]

A task label may reveal the tested hypothesis &
The compared labels and all fixed control data are
identical; the coefficient enters the amplitude.\\[4pt]

A phase difference is an exact real-number decoder &
The phase instrument sees a cosine and has aliases.\\[4pt]

A coarse invariant failure outcome guarantees
invariance of a raw failure log &
Exporting the raw Bell failure distinction enlarges
the boundary and can break the invariance.\\[4pt]

An injective one-parameter response is tomography &
The effects omit Bloch directions, and the field
moments have an infinite-dimensional kernel.\\[4pt]

Reference preservation means fixed conditional
reference states &
A conditional reference may be steered. The
unconditional channel acts as the reference identity.\\[4pt]

Finite adaptive completeness preserves every gap &
A later replacement channel erases it. A retained
prefix record gives the stated lower bound.\\[4pt]

A channel error validates a numerical coefficient &
An enclosure needs its own analytical or numerical
justification.\\[4pt]

The clock may be reused after destruction &
Every new quantum input needs a separately supplied
factor and resource charge.\\[4pt]

A clock reading creates or consumes geometric time &
Only a finite encoding is consumed. The prescribed
time axis remains.\\[4pt]

Scheduled ancestry reconstructs the metric cone &
Causal embedding is a separate certificate on the
unchanged host.\\[4pt]

A finite route derives a microscopic interaction &
The route uses declared stroboscopic finite controls.\\[4pt]

X-J-ST repairs the fourth-order master residual &
Its action is unchanged, so the residual is unchanged.\\[4pt]

Setting \(\lambda=0\) gives the full free theory &
It removes the added quartic vertex, not all
reference interactions.\\[4pt]

The centered sector is the only possible free-BV
recovery condition &
It is sufficient. The displayed tadpole also
vanishes whenever \(Ah=0\).\\[4pt]

A new source file is an executed registration &
The companion metadata below is proposed only.\\
\bottomrule
\end{longtable}

%=====================================================================
\section{Documentary comparisons not used as proof transfers}
\label{app:documentary}
%=====================================================================

The characteristic records XIV-H, XIV-I, and XIV-J
distinguish a historical internal-amplitude stop,
the narrower I2 construction, and missing full
characteristic maps at I3/J2. Technical XV-B interfaces
do not themselves admit the full coefficient.
Their version-specific statements are not advanced
by the finite moment construction here
\cite{CharacteristicRecords}.

Likewise, the prepared-source and kernel-counterterm
records have their own domains and prescription
qualifications \cite{PreparedRecords}. This manuscript
neither discharges XVI-N nor updates XVI-O's stated
\loc{NOT_CLOSED} O.1 record. It makes no extrapolation
to other versions or prescriptions.

The supplied descriptions of OpenAI Families 282,
362, and 376 are documentary comparisons of
finite-interface and finite-certificate styles
\cite{OpenAIRecords}. No such paper is a premise of
the coefficient construction, the TV identities,
the instruments, or recovery. No catalogue theorem,
reported formalization, or family-wide verification
is asserted here.

A finite dictionary is a finite collection of tasks,
not a replacement for the infinite-dimensional
field domain or for a missing distributional
composition theorem.

%=====================================================================
\section{Proposed companion integration record}
\label{app:integration}
%=====================================================================

This appendix is a proposal, not an executed repository
transaction. It does not register, hash, compile, or
test the source.

\paragraph{Proposed routing note.}
X-J-ST constructs a second charged coefficient and a
selective amplitude package on the unchanged prescribed
I-B/X-A-ST host. It proves a positive TV gap on finite
dictionary inputs and complete destructive instruments.
The result is not quantum BRST, not a characteristic
coefficient, not continuum acquisition, and not a premise
of an earlier sheet. The convolution obstruction is
unrepaired. The trees are retained once. Common-direction
charge matching is local and does not identify a reference
for the whole convolution gauge algebra.

\begin{verbatim}
identifier: X-J-ST
sourceStatus: proposed
placement: after X-I-ST, before XI-A
track: ramp
problems:
  - relational
  - products
nearUv: true

classicalObject:
  type: ghost-number-zero compact scalar moment
  source: finite third polarization of X-I-ST V_a
  formalOrderLabel: kappa^3
  firstWeightedChargeOrder: kappa^4
  actionModified: false
  sameModelConvolutionReference: not constructed

selectivePackage:
  finiteSuppliedDictionary: true
  positiveTVGap: proved for specified encodings
  failureOutcomeRetained: true
  untouchedReferencesIncluded: true
  informationalCompleteness: false
  continuumAcquisition: not constructed
  wholeGaugeMatching: not established
  localCommonDirectionMatching: constructed

obligations:
  second-coefficient-not-quantum-product:
    Classical action polarization is not a quantum product.
  selective-TV-not-complete-orbit:
    A positive gap is not whole-orbit reconstruction.
  residual-instrument-not-acquisition:
    Supplied finite encodings are not acquired continuum fields.
  convolution-gap-unrepaired:
    No same-model whole-algebra reference is identified.
  local-match-not-whole-algebra:
    The independent charge direction remains visible.
  formal-order-not-real-gain:
    Encoding parameters do not specialize a nilpotent coupling.

documentaryConnections:
  X-Enter-ST: selective and matching comparison; not a premise
  X-I-ST: explicit retained action interface
  X-H-ST: relative BV and complete-report comparison
  X-G-ST: unchanged free causal normalization
  X-F-ST: tree packet retained once
  X-A-conv-ST: independent unrepaired gap
  I-B: prescribed host and finite permissions
  En-series: complete clock, schedule, and route comparisons
  OpenAI: documentary separation only; not a premise

timeLandmark:
  proposed: true
  reason: a complete finite destructive clock is explicitly defined

emergenceStatus: not constructed
includeInEmergenceSources: false

registryEditsExecuted: false
repositoryTestsExecuted: false
compilationAsserted: false
numericalExecutionAsserted: false
machineVerificationAsserted: false
independentExecutionAsserted: false
\end{verbatim}

Actual integration must use the repository's real schema,
current source identifiers, and actual connection and
index tests. No expected connection count, array-length
increment, passing test result, or completed freeze is
invented before that transaction occurs.

%=====================================================================
\section*{Declarations}
\addcontentsline{toc}{section}{Declarations}

\paragraph{Analytical scope.}
The new coefficients are compact classical response
moments on smooth off-shell scalar data. Their
independence and local charges are proved explicitly.
No new interacting action, fourth-order completion,
Koszul--Tate resolution, physical cohomology, or
interacting free-carrier transport is claimed.

\paragraph{Operational scope.}
The finite instruments are specified on supplied
register inputs, all declared selective outputs, and
untouched references. They do not acquire the input
coefficient from a continuum field or derive a
microscopic detector.

\paragraph{Attribution.}
The classical vertex and BV interface are those of
the supplied X-I-ST source. The amplitude and
conditional phase-instrument mechanisms are credited
to X-Enter/X-Enter-ST. The present continuation
constructs the explicit moment pair, its independent
charges and local matching boundary, and the
failure-retaining finite-dictionary assembly.

\paragraph{Verification.}
No successful \loc{pdflatex} execution, numerical
quadrature, symbolic-program execution, proof-assistant
verification, hardware implementation, repository
registration, independent execution, independent
referee approval, or journal acceptance is asserted.
The source is standalone and intended for pdfLaTeX;
the mathematical claims are the written proofs above.

%=====================================================================
\begin{thebibliography}{99}
\addcontentsline{toc}{section}{References}

\bibitem{XIST}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-I-ST: A supported finite-order classical BV
deformation on a prescribed conical Enter spacetime}.
Supplied source \loc{X-I-ST.tex}, with author field
Ngo Cheung.
Third-order compact scalar vertex, polynomial-lift
residual, centered free-BV comparison, and complete
finite supplied-report instruments.
The supplied source is the version used here;
no independent compilation or registration is inferred.

\bibitem{XEnterST}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-Enter-ST: Readout closure of an obstructed
convolution coefficient on a prescribed conical host}.
\loc{X-Enter-ST.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-Enter-ST}.
Especially \loc{thm:amplitude},
\loc{thm:secondorder}, \loc{eq:TV},
\loc{prop:matching}, \loc{thm:relational},
\loc{thm:clock}, \loc{thm:locality}, and
\loc{thm:route}.
The second convolution reference is an additional
hypothesis there, not an input silently supplied here.

\bibitem{XEnter}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-Enter}.
\loc{X-Enter.tex}, version 1.
Version-qualified passages supplied with the request.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-Enter}.
Selective amplitude visibility, retained-order tests,
and conditional two-coefficient readout.

\bibitem{XHST}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-H-ST: Relative classical BV structure and
complete instruments for supplied residual reports}.
\loc{X-H-ST.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-H-ST}.
Signed classical lift, non-descent, background tadpole,
and complete finite report interfaces.

\bibitem{XGST}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-G-ST: Free causal BRST compatibility and a
variational upgrade obstruction}.
\loc{X-G-ST.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-G-ST}.
Free auxiliary--ghost normalization, causal BRST,
positive reciprocity diagnostic, and scoped fish and
wavefront statements.

\bibitem{XG}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{Landmark X-G: The normalized BRST multiplet and
the one-loop background gate: proved compatibility
conditions, an exact-upgrade obstruction, and the
remaining nonlocal extension problem}.
\loc{X-G.tex}, version 1.
Version-qualified source record supplied with the request.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-G}.

\bibitem{XFST}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-F-ST: Three fixed-width retarded trees and the
background identity}.
\loc{X-F-ST.tex}, version 1.
Version-qualified supplied manuscript record.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-F-ST}.
The retained three-tree packet is a comparison object,
not reconstructed by the report instrument.

\bibitem{XConv}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-A-conv}.
\loc{X-A-conv.tex}, version 1.
Version-qualified supplied manuscript record.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-A-conv}.
Frozen classical convolution prescription and its
positive covariance defect.

\bibitem{XConvST}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-A-conv-ST}.
Version 1, supplied manuscript record.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-A-conv-ST}.
Independent convolution obstruction, support certificates,
and complete finite report locality.

\bibitem{IB}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{I-B: A Finite Enter Spacetime:
Calibrated Destructive Time Readout on a Prescribed
Conical Product}.
\loc{I-B-v1.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/I-B}.
Prescribed conical worldsheet, finite complete clock,
calibration, scheduled locality, and regular transport.

\bibitem{XAST}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{X-A-ST}.
Version 1, predecessor source record supplied with the
request.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/X-A-ST}.
Supported completion chart, fixed positive width,
signature ledger, and plateau contract.

\bibitem{CheungEnter}
N.~Cheung,
``The Enter Calculus: A Linear Quantum Lambda Calculus
with an Operational Characterization of Measurement,''
\emph{Frontiers in Physics}, volume 14 (2026),
doi:10.3389/fphy.2026.1954943.
\url{https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/physics/articles/10.3389/fphy.2026.1954943/abstract}.
Publisher advance article record; final pagination
is not assumed.
Specified Born semantics and the separate
class-relative operational characterization are not
identified.

\bibitem{EnterI}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{Manuscript I}.
\loc{I.tex}, version 2.
Version-qualified supplied manuscript record.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/I}.
Finite operational characterization of destructive
measurement inside its stated structural class;
not continuum field acquisition.

\bibitem{EnterPhilosophy}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{The Philosophy of Enter:
Destructive Readout, Quantum Recovery, and the
Refusal of Identification}.
\loc{EntPhil-v2.tex}, version 2.
Introductory essay, Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/enter}.
Interpretive separation of readout, recovery,
thermodynamic specification, and physical identification.

\bibitem{En09}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{Realization of Relational Time by Destructive
Enter on a Clock Register}.
\loc{En09-A.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/En09-A}.
Complete destructive-clock channel and arbitrary
reference extension; dynamical interpretation has
additional hypotheses.

\bibitem{En03}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{En03-A}.
\loc{En03-A.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/En03-A}.
Complete scheduled block interfaces and exact
backwards-support theorem.

\bibitem{VIIE}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{VII-E}.
\loc{VII-E.tex}, version 1.
Version-qualified supplied manuscript record.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/VII-E}.
Observation boundaries and prescribed schedule locality.

\bibitem{En08A}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{En08-A}.
\loc{En08-A.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/En08-A}.
Scheduler consistency versus additional Lorentz-cone
representation hypotheses.

\bibitem{En08B}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{Resource-controlled operational approximation
of null boundary transport}.
\loc{En08-B.tex}, version 1.
Enter Calculus Companion.
\url{https://enter.grok.me/browse/En08-B}.
Finite reference-preserving transport relative to
prescribed geometric and operational data.

\bibitem{En02B}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{En02-B}.
Version 1, supplied manuscript excerpts.
Enter Calculus Companion.
Finite complete-history channel soundness and
live-name resource certificates.

\bibitem{En02C}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{En02-C}.
Version 1, supplied manuscript excerpts.
Enter Calculus Companion.
Reference-preserving sequential soundness and
explicit storage ledgers.
No radiation recovery task is imported here.

\bibitem{FRBV}
K.~Fredenhagen and K.~Rejzner,
``Batalin--Vilkovisky formalism in the functional
approach to classical field theory,''
\emph{Communications in Mathematical Physics}
\textbf{314} (2012), 93--127.
\url{https://arxiv.org/abs/1101.5112}.
Classical functional BV framework.
Its global hypotheses are not transferred to the
regular conical product.

\bibitem{DaviesLewis}
E.~B.~Davies and J.~T.~Lewis,
``An operational approach to quantum probability,''
\emph{Communications in Mathematical Physics}
\textbf{17} (1970), 239--260.
doi:10.1007/BF01647093.
\url{https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01647093}.
External instrument framework; the finite maps used
in this paper are proved directly.

\bibitem{Watrous}
J.~Watrous,
\emph{The Theory of Quantum Information}.
Cambridge University Press, 2018.
Author manuscript and errata:
\url{https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~watrous/TQI/}.
Finite channels, complete references, trace distance,
and diamond-norm comparison.

\bibitem{CharacteristicRecords}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{XIV-H}, \emph{XIV-I}, and \emph{XIV-J},
version 1, and technical \emph{XV-B}, version 2.
Version-qualified manuscript passages supplied with
the request.
Internal-amplitude constructions, reconstruction
descent, partial characteristic references, and the
unconstructed full-map/admission boundaries.

\bibitem{PreparedRecords}
N.~Cheung,
\emph{XVI-N}, revision r12, and
\emph{XVI-O}, revision o70-sync.
Version-qualified passages supplied with the request.
Prepared-insertion and prescription-qualified kernel
boundaries only; no calculation from those programmes
is performed here.

\bibitem{OpenAIRecords}
OpenAI,
\emph{Mathematics catalogue and finite-interface
manuscript descriptions}.
Supplied documentary descriptions, including
Families 282, 362, and 376.
No family theorem or reported formalization is used
as a premise or independently verified here.

\end{thebibliography}

\end{document}