Manuscript I-B-VP@3 · I-B-VP-v3.tex · section · 93c04eb4

Retained SAE checks

Retained SAE checks · lines 3709–3783

Back to manuscript

C4 At , the tested orders were . The source reports small- asymptotic relative errors and at . For large , it reports and . It reports , agreement of leading stress coefficients to 12 printed digits, structural relations to , and conservation and trace residuals at most . The conjugate-mode swap reportedly agrees in square and stress to , with opposite current.

The small-radius tests lie in regimes compatible with the corrected Theorem thm:small; they do not establish the incorrect predecessor remainder uniformly for all .

C5 For , and a positive matrix with reported eigenvalues , the source reports conservation , trace , current conservation , and . The rotation rule was reported exact. The off-diagonal-to-zero limit reportedly agrees with the diagonal result to , and the line family integral with its closed form to .

The SAE text additionally reports large-radius relative error at , described as decreasing like , and a small-radius scaled error at . These tests are not extended to arbitrary boundary charts.

C7 The reported bound-state diagnostics are:

  • after pole subtraction, values on both sides of , differing by ;

  • an algebraic tail coefficient , agreeing to at ;

  • the Struve identity to , the longitudinal split identity to , and the principal-value Hankel identity below ;

  • the bound-state residue matching to 12 digits;

  • logarithmic asymptotic tests at , with two-term relative error at , described as decreasing like .

Filgueiras–Moraes report Eight comparisons were reported at most . The energy scale and longitudinal term must be restored when comparing the dimensionless expression with their equation (10).

would strengthen these reports. Supply the actual scripts, exact parameter encodings, dependency versions, raw values, precision schedules, quadrature tolerances, oscillatory truncations, pole prescriptions, certified tails, and image-boundary handling. Until then the retained numbers are comparisons, not rigorous error enclosures or proof of a universal identity.

Nearby in this section