Manuscript Oai119-A@1 · Oai119-A.tex · section · fdff7292
A classical kernel does not specify a quantum extension
Stages 3 and 4: evaluation and hypothesis changes › A classical kernel does not specify a quantum extension · lines 1502–1553
Here is an explicit non-identification, used only as a comparison. For a qubit let
and
where is the Pauli bit flip. The two CPTP maps and agree on every diagonal input. They therefore implement the same classical binary symmetric transition on computational-basis data.
Nevertheless,
The output trace distance is . The second extension is measure-and-prepare; the classical transition table alone did not select that extension.
This is the kind of distinction between records and full quantum outputs emphasized by Cheung's readout and residual comparisons CheungVIIIA,CheungVIIIB,CheungEn07A. The standard measure-and-prepare characterization is given in HSR.
Similarly, is a classical affinity: for the two Bernoulli laws
one has
The fact that classical affinities admit diagonal-matrix representations does not prove an inequality for arbitrary noncommuting density operators, entangled inputs, or collective POVMs.
Displayed formulas in this passage
unlabeled · line 1506
unlabeled · line 1510
unlabeled · line 1523
unlabeled · line 1540
unlabeled · line 1546