Manuscript X-H-ST@1 · X-H-ST.tex · proposition · 943aa27e
Proposition: Positive upgrade incompatibility
Unrestricted breaking and variational reciprocity are different › The exact source-preserving upgrade obstruction · lines 1170–1220 · proof included or linked
X-H-ST@1#prop:recip, X-H-ST@1#eq:W
The data (eq:recipdata) give
The background can be supported in the retained regular reserve, and the detecting free inputs can be replaced by free inputs with compact Cauchy data.
Proof. On a free input, (eq:typed) gives . The relevant Lie components are
There are also components but no spatial–spatial components. For tensors of this form, . Spatial Laplacians integrate to zero, and
Thus . Two integrations by parts yield (eq:W).
Choose an observation event . Since , a small spatial ball satisfies
Choose supported in . For compact-Cauchy replacements, choose initial data equal to those of on the initial causal shadow of a neighbourhood of , and compactly cut off the data outside a larger ball. Finite propagation preserves near , so the local pairing is unchanged BGP.
Displayed formulas in this passage
X-H-ST@1#eq:W · line 1173
unlabeled · line 1188
unlabeled · line 1197
unlabeled · line 1207