Manuscript XIX-A@1 · XIX-A.tex · proposition · e30d8062
Proposition: Scope records do not transfer between identifiers
Fifth refusal: Family 271 and reported Lean scope · lines 1407–1422 · proof included or linked
XIX-A@1#prop:catalogue
Let a documentary scope record list the singleton identifier set . That record supplies no formalization claim for VI, Em02-E, X-A, VIII-A/B, or the other Family 271 identifiers. It supplies no premise for a clock-separation theorem.
Proof. The listed identifiers are part of the record's declared scope. None of the other identifiers belongs to the singleton set. A mathematical identification or proof transfer would require an additional statement and its hypotheses; membership of one identifier supplies no such statement. The proposition concerns the scope of a record, not correctness of the recorded proof.