Manuscript XVI-A@1 · XVI-A.tex · section · 8177be5d

Gauge-fixed and Einstein-shell conditions are not identified

The predecessor obstructions remain separate › Gauge-fixed and Einstein-shell conditions are not identified · lines 504–526

Back to manuscript

The supplied XI-F excerpt contains a cubic transformation law with both a gauge-fixing companion and an Einstein-equation contribution. The supplied XI-G coverage also states that its witness lies on the gauge-fixed shell and off the Einstein shell XIF,XIG.

Accordingly:

  • the gauge companion is retained;

  • the Einstein-shell contribution is retained;

  • a gauge-fixed free-shell condition is not used as a substitute for an Einstein-shell hypothesis;

  • a transformation law for the unramped response is not asserted for the prepared response without proof.

The relevant prepared terms have not been supplied as explicit kernels. Retaining them is a requirement on a future derivation, not a claim that they have already been constructed.